Workplace problems are not always what they first appear to be. A complaint about an employee, a sudden drop in performance or an allegation of bullying can point to deeper issues within a business. Understanding what is really happening before taking action is essential to making fair and informed decisions.
For New Zealand small businesses, conducting a workplace investigation can be particularly challenging. Managers often work closely with their employees, making it difficult to separate personal relationships, assumptions and emotions from the facts.
In this HRtoolkit training video, Lisa Mackay, Managing Director of HRtoolkit Ltd, draws on over 30 years of HR experience to explain how employers can investigate workplace issues, gather reliable evidence and identify the underlying causes of problems.
Workplace investigations can begin for many reasons, including employee complaints, customer concerns, disciplinary matters or unexpected changes in business performance.
Lisa explains that employers should pay attention to patterns that might otherwise go unnoticed.
A decline in profitability, for example, may not be caused by poor employee performance. It could result from increased operating costs, outdated pricing, changes in customer spending or inefficient working practices.
Reviewing these factors can help employers identify the real source of a problem rather than responding to its symptoms.
One of the most important principles of any workplace investigation is maintaining an open mind.
An employee’s previous behaviour, reputation or disciplinary history should not automatically determine the outcome of a new complaint.
As Lisa explains, the purpose of an investigation is to establish what happened and make a reasonable decision based on the available evidence.
“I’m just here to find out facts, not make assumptions or prejudgments.”
Lisa Mackay, Managing Director, HRtoolkit Ltd (23:39)
In New Zealand employment matters, decisions are generally assessed using the balance of probabilities rather than the criminal standard of proof beyond reasonable doubt.
Employers need sufficient reliable information to reach a reasonable conclusion, while ensuring that everyone involved has been treated fairly.
A thorough workplace investigation often begins with reviewing existing records.
Employee files, timesheets, financial reports, customer complaints and previous exit interviews can provide important context before formal interviews begin.
Lisa shares an example involving repeated allegations of workplace bullying. Although the situation initially appeared to be an ongoing disagreement between two employees, a review of previous exit interviews revealed a broader pattern of concerns involving a manager.
This highlights why employers should examine the available evidence before forming conclusions.
Once the initial evidence has been reviewed, employers need to identify relevant witnesses and prepare appropriate interview questions.
Lisa recommends asking consistent, open questions that encourage people to describe what they personally witnessed rather than repeating assumptions or workplace gossip.
Useful questions include:
The investigator should remain neutral throughout the conversation, avoiding leading questions or comments that suggest a preferred outcome.
Lisa also discusses the importance of observing how people respond during interviews. However, nervousness, emotional reactions or changes in body language should not automatically be interpreted as dishonesty.
Employees may feel anxious simply because they are involved in a formal investigation.
Maintaining objectivity can be particularly difficult when managers already know the employees involved.
Personal opinions, previous experiences and workplace relationships can influence how evidence is interpreted.
“As the investigator, you need to be saying, ‘Hey, look, I’m just here to find out facts, not make assumptions or prejudgments.’”
Lisa Mackay, Managing Director, HRtoolkit Ltd (23:39)
Employers should avoid agreeing with allegations before the evidence has been reviewed or making comments that could suggest a decision has already been reached.
A professional and impartial approach helps protect the integrity of the investigation and gives employees greater confidence in the process.
Fair process is essential when investigating employee conduct.
Lisa explains that employees should be informed about the investigation, understand the concerns being examined and have an opportunity to respond.
They should also be advised of their ability to have a support person present during relevant meetings.
Once the evidence has been gathered, the employee concerned should have a meaningful opportunity to respond to the findings.
In some situations, their response may identify additional witnesses or information that requires further investigation.
Employers should consider this information with an open mind before reaching a final conclusion.
An investigation and a disciplinary process are not necessarily the same thing. Where disciplinary action may be considered, employers need to follow an appropriate and fair process.
Completing an investigation does not always resolve the underlying workplace tension.
Where complaints involve bullying, harassment or ongoing conflict, employees may continue working together after the investigation has concluded.
Lisa emphasises the importance of keeping complainants appropriately informed while respecting the privacy of everyone involved.
She also recommends facilitated discussions where appropriate to help restore working relationships.
“There will be a need to rebuild that trust.”
Lisa Mackay, Managing Director, HRtoolkit Ltd (32:04)
Rebuilding trust may involve clearer communication, conflict management training or facilitated conversations between employees.
The objective is not simply to close the investigation, but to address the underlying issues and support a healthier working environment.
Effective workplace investigations require patience, objectivity and a willingness to look beyond the initial complaint.
By reviewing evidence, asking neutral questions, allowing employees to respond and carefully assessing the findings, employers can make better informed decisions and reduce the risk of further workplace conflict.
For New Zealand small businesses, having clear HR policies and procedures can also help managers respond more confidently when workplace concerns arise.
Explore HRtoolkit’s practical HR resources, templates and professional support to help manage workplace issues and employee relations.
Lisa Mackay | Managing Director, HRtoolkit Ltd
Lisa holds a Postgraduate Diploma in Human Resource Management and has over 30 years of experience working in HR with small businesses. Through HRtoolkit, she helps New Zealand employers navigate workplace challenges with practical advice, HR resources and professional support.
This video provides general HR guidance. Employers should consider their individual circumstances, current New Zealand employment law and professional advice where appropriate.
Related Products
Find our guides relative to this video here, or browse our full catalogue below.