First interviews should be 30–45 minutes long, with expectations set clearly with candidates to avoid negative perceptions.
Bias Mitigation: Avoid the Halo/Horns effect, where non-work-related attributes (e.g., shared hobbies or interests) unfairly influence the assessment of a candidate’s ability.
Skill Assessment: Distinguish between innate skills (non-trainable) and trainable skills (e.g., specific software like Xero vs. general accounting principles).
Team Fit: Consider whether a candidate complements the existing team culture or provides a necessary “shake-up” to prevent company stagnation.
Maintain an informal setting to relax candidates, listen more than talk, and probe answers for clarity to avoid “parroting”.
Use situational questions rather than general ones (e.g., “Tell me about a time when…” instead of “Are you a team player?”).
Quality/Accuracy: Asking for specific tools or tricks used to avoid mistakes when busy.
Probing for “out of the box” solutions and subsequent learnings.
Assessing the ability to handle remote or lonely roles through descriptive experience or realistic expectations.
Use a 1–5 scale immediately after interviews, starting everyone at 3 and adjusting based on positive or negative evidence 3.
To identify strengths, weaknesses, and allow you to probe for self-awareness.
Conduct these personally rather than through agents to avoid biased reporting. Specifically ask “Would you re-employ?” and listen for tonality. Verify the relationship of the referee to ensure they were a supervisor, not just a friend.
Clear package levels should be established during phone screenings to avoid late-stage surprises or candidates using offers as leverage with current employers.
Complete police, criminal record, and driver’s license checks early in the process.
Related Products
Find our guides relative to this video here, or browse our full catalogue below.